American History X 2x
I borrowed a slew of movies from friends of mine a while ago. American History X has sat, untouched for weeks, on top of our TV cabinet.
Though it’s been nearly ten years since I first saw it, I couldn’t bear to watch the curb scene again.
And I mostly avoided it. I wound up watching the actual moment peering through my fingers, but it wasn’t as graphic as I remember. It’s more the fear in the victim’s face before the act that sets up the terror of the moment. (By the way, this is not so much a I-don’t-want-to-give-it-away-moment as an I-don’t-want-to-describe-it.)
Anyway, the film is a mixture of brilliance and maudlin. Edward Norton’s white supremacist, Derek, (who predates Ryan Gosling’s Jewish neo-nazi by two years) is clearly the emotional center of the film, despite narration by his younger brother.
I have trouble connecting with Norton’s voice, though. There’s some strange Fight Club/Primal Fear holdover that makes it difficult for me to engage with his dialogue. It’s like I mistrust what his character is telling me… His body language and intensity, however, is why he’s one of the most highly-regarded actors around.
Horribly, the curb scene is the highlight of Norton’s performance. The manic joy in his eyes as he awaits arrest is both repellent and intoxicating. In the next scene, the moment is made all the more compelling via the deadness in the eyes of Cam, Norton’s character’s mentor.
There are highs and lows, most of which are summed up by the uneven, heartstringy ending. After a dramatic moment, we’re left with more questions than answers of what this might mean for the characters. The soundtrack during the rather predictable jail rape scene is overwrought and belies an unnecessary terror on the part of the composer (I feel as though few movie composers find themselves prey to incarcerated gang rapes).
Derek’s brother Danny (Edward Furlong) narrates and acts well, and there are strong moments from Doris (Beverly D’Angelo), the brothers’ mother. There’s a strangely stilted performance from the almost uniformely fine Elliot Gould; there’s no question he was directed poorly in both of his scenes.
Even if you have bad memories from the first time, American History X is worth a re-watch. I’m not sure if it’s a good thing or a bad thing that it made me want to re-watch The Believer as well. There’s only so much neo-nazism I can take - it’s not really the genre I was looking for this week.
Sphere: Related Content